MLB Home Run Props for Friday, September 25: Best Odds on Abrams, Alvarez, and Gelof
September Slump Creates Massive Value on Tonight’s Home Run Props
The final Friday of the MLB regular season is here, and September baseball has a funny way of hiding talent as attention shifts elsewhere. For anyone hunting MLB player props and home run bets tonight, the numbers are hard to ignore. The betting market has mispriced several sluggers, and that creates genuine opportunity for anyone paying attention. Below are the top home run predictions and parlay plays for Friday, Sept. 25, straight from the latest odds and matchups.
Home Run Prediction: CJ Abrams — Overlooked at Extended Odds
CJ Abrams is getting priced at levels that don’t match what the market has been seeing all season. At roughly 7.2x, Abrams sits well above his typical pricing near 5x, which makes little sense given what the numbers show. Facing a projected starter in Justin Hagenman — though the MLB app still listed the pitcher as TBF as of this afternoon — Abrams is getting a matchup that heavily favors a left-handed bat.
His numbers against right-handers sit at a .900 OPS with 25 home runs on the season, and he hasn’t cooled off in September. Abrams slammed two homers in his most recent series and another one against the Cardinals. The wind is blowing in tonight, but lefty bats are better equipped to cut through that breeze coming from left field.
- First pitch: 6:45 p.m. ET
- Where to watch: Nationals.TV, WPIX
Home Run Prediction: Yordan Alvarez — Best Matchup on the Entire Slate
If you’re looking for the single best home run matchup tonight, it’s hard to find one better than Yordan Alvarez in Sacramento. The Astros slugger is listed at 3.7x, but most would agree that 3.2x is closer to fair value. On the other side is Jacob Lopez, a pitcher who looks like he wants to call it a season after surrendering 10 runs in his last start and 19 runs across his previous three outings — all in just 12.1 innings.
Lopez has also allowed multiple home runs in three of his last four games. Alvarez has drilled him once in five prior meetings, and the conditions are stacked in his favor. Winds are blowing out, it is the best hitting weather September has to offer, and the pitcher looks fatigued. This is a situation where the price is right and everything else lines up.
- First pitch: 9:40 p.m. ET
- Where to watch: NBCSCA, Space City Network
Home Run Prediction: Zack Gelof — Sutter Health Park Does the Rest
Zack Gelof is a run-not-walk trade at an extended price tonight. The Athletics third baseman launched two home runs in Sacramento last night and has five over his last ten games, bringing his season total to 22 dingers. What makes this pick compelling is the venue itself — Sutter Health Park finished as the best Over park of the season, with home runs landing at a rate above 60%.
Hunter Brown on the mound is a big reason the market has priced Gelof at 8.1x instead of a more reasonable 6x. The familiarity exists — Gelof has faced Brown 14 times — and while the career numbers aren’t overwhelming, Gelof’s .936 OPS at home dwarfs his .664 road mark. The combination of a hitter-friendly ballpark, outgoing winds, and decent temperatures makes this one of the best environmental hitting conditions on tonight’s entire board.
- First pitch: 9:40 p.m. ET
- Where to watch: NBCSCA, Space City Network
Best Home Run Combo for September 25
For those looking to stack the best value plays into a single parlay, the three picks above combine into a compelling bundle. Below is a summary of the lineup and the combined payout:
| Player to Hit a Home Run | Odds |
|---|---|
 CJ Abrams | 7.2x |
 Yordan Alvarez | 3.7x |
 Zack Gelof | 8.1x |
| Combined Parlay 191.0x | |
Odds are subject to change and were accurate at the time of publishing. These picks reflect genuine value based on matchup analysis, environmental factors, and market pricing inefficiencies — not speculation.
Josh Inglis’ 2026 Transparency Record
Home run picks: 41-152, -10.2 units
Wrapping Up: Why Tonight’s Board Is Worth a Look
September baseball has a way of separating the casual bettors from the ones paying attention. With the season winding down, pitchers are tired, matchups are clearer, and the market often overreacts to small-sample noise. Tonight’s slate offers three distinctly different situations — a lefty slugger getting long odds against a questionable starter, a superstar in a pitcher’s worst nightmare, and a power hitter in one of the most favorable home parks in the league.
Whether you’re looking for a single play or a three-leg parlay at 191.0x, the value is there if you’re willing to do the homework. As always, manage your bankroll responsibly and check for any late roster or weather changes before placing your bets.
Sports, News, Entertainment, Online, Leisure, MLB Baseball, Sports Betting, September Baseball, Player Props, Fantasy Baseball, Betting Odds
