5 Angus Gardner
Gardner’s approachable, conversational style has made him one of the most recognizable judges in the world. Starting young and rising quickly, he was named World Rugby Referee of the Year in 2018.
Some prefer stricter officiating, but Gardner’s steady hand in high-profile matches has earned him respect around the world.
4 Nika Amashukeli
Resilience defines Amashukeli’s path. Early in his career, he was attacked after a home match, a moment that would end many a refereeing career. Instead, he moved on and eventually reached the Rugby World Cup stage.
He is admired for his honesty, knowledge and willingness to communicate openly. Even with occasional disagreements, his honesty stands out.
3 Holly Davidson
A pioneer in rugby refereeing, Davidson became the first woman to referee both a European final and a Springboks Test. Known for her reserved leadership and sharp decision-making, she is often described as professional and authoritative.
By focusing on performance rather than hype, she continues to redefine the craft of judging.
2 Nick Berry
Berry’s first career as a linebacker came to an abrupt end due to a concussion, but refereeing opened a second chapter that he fully embraced. His rise into the elite ranks was rapid, although not without controversy, especially during the Lions’ series in South Africa.
However, his calmness and compassion for his players won him loyal supporters.
1 Ben O’Keefe
O’Keeffe is widely regarded as setting the standard in modern rugby refereeing. Known for remaining calm under pressure, he holds national records for Tests and first-class performances, and has watched everything from World Cups to Lions clashes.
Although he has faced intense criticism online from time to time, his measured responses and consistent actions have earned him widespread admiration. He is considered by many to be the most reliable judge in the world today.